Homeowners Insurance (and Rentals): How to Get Quotes You Can Actually Compare

Whether you live in the home or rent it out, the trick to smart protection is locking specs before you shop. Here’s a clear guide to homeowners insurance quotes and what changes when you need homeowners insurance for rental property (landlord coverage).

a-clean-modern-split-screen-illustration_Kli6VaOQQKia7y7BERNgKg_eB5INsb7Tg6o9ys-qCFaLQ

  • Owner-occupied vs. rental: which policy do you need?

Owner-occupied homes: Usually HO-3 (standard) or HO-5 (broader/open-perils). Covers the structure, your belongings, loss of use (hotel/temporary housing), and personal liability.

Rental property (you don’t live there): Ask for a landlord policy (often DP-3). Key differences:

Loss of rents (not loss of use) if a covered claim makes the unit uninhabitable.

Premises/landlord liability for injuries and tenant claims.

Limited coverage for landlord furnishings/appliances (stove, fridge, blinds); tenant belongings are not covered (they need renters insurance).

Vacancy/tenant screening requirements may apply.

House-sharing/short-term rental: You’ll likely need a home-sharing or business-use endorsement (or a dedicated landlord/STR policy). Standard homeowners forms often exclude business activity.

  • What to set before requesting homeowners insurance quotes

Give every insurer the same specs so the prices are apples-to-apples:

Dwelling limit (Coverage A): Based on reconstruction cost (not market value). Ask the agent to share the rebuild estimate inputs.

Deductible: Pick one (e.g., $1,000 or $2,500). Know if wind/hail uses a separate percentage deductible.

Personal property: Replacement Cost (RCV) vs. Actual Cash Value (ACV). For rentals, set limits for landlord contents only.

Liability: Commonly $300k–$500k; consider a $1M umbrella if you have assets, a pool, or rentals.

Must-have endorsements:

Water/sewer backup (very common claim)

Ordinance or law (code upgrades after a loss)

Service line (buried utilities)

Equipment breakdown (HVAC, appliances)

For rentals: loss of rents, landlord furnishings, additional insured (e.g., property manager)

  • Price drivers (so quotes make sense)

Roof age/material, distance to fire services, local weather risks (hail, wind, wildfire), claims history, protective devices (monitored alarms, water shutoff sensors), and—where allowed—credit-based insurance scores. Condition and updates (roof, wiring, plumbing, HVAC) matter for both owner-occupied and rental property quotes.

  • Landlord policy essentials (homeowners insurance for rental property)

Dwelling: Aim for open-perils coverage on the structure; confirm RCV settlement on the building.

Loss of rents: Choose a realistic monthly limit and time period (e.g., 12 months).

Liability: Landlord-focused liability with medical payments for guests; add your LLC/property manager as additional insured where appropriate.

Tenant requirements: Lease should require renters insurance and name you as an interested party (so you’re notified of cancellations).

Vacancy clauses: Coverage can change if the home is vacant >30–60 days—ask for specifics.

  • How to shop (and win) the quote game

Gather data: Year built, square footage, roof age/material, updates by year (roof/electrical/plumbing/HVAC), distance to hydrant/fire station, security systems, dogs/pool, prior claims. For rentals: tenant type, lease term, occupancy rate.

Request 3–5 quotes with identical specs (limits, deductible, endorsements). Ask for RCV vs. ACV roof terms in writing.

Bundle with auto/umbrella for discounts; ask about mitigation credits (impact-resistant roof, shutters, wildfire hardening, monitored alarms).

Compare line-by-line: Watch for water-backup limits, ordinance & law percentage, loss-of-rents amount, and any wind/hail percent deductible.

Adjust once, re-run: If too pricey, raise your all-perils deductible (keep wind/hail sensible), or trim optional endorsements—not core coverage.

  • RFQ template (paste this to get clean homeowners insurance quotes)

“Please quote: [address]. Occupancy: [primary home / rental with 12-month lease / short-term rental]. Year built [ ], roof [type/age], updates [elec/plumb/HVAC years]. Request: Coverage A = $[rebuild estimate], deductible $[ ], liability $[ ]. Add water backup ($10k+), ordinance & law (25%+), service line, equipment breakdown. If rental: include loss of rents (12 months, $[ ]/mo), landlord furnishings $[ ], and list [property manager/LLC] as additional insured. Specify roof settlement (RCV vs ACV), any wind/hail % deductible, and show discounts (bundle, alarms). Provide full forms/endorsement numbers.”

  • Two quick examples

Owner-occupied, budget-smart: HO-3 with RCV on structure & contents, $2,000 deductible, $500k liability, plus water backup and service line. Bundling with auto trims 10–20%.

Single-family rental: DP-3 (landlord) with RCV on structure, $2,500 deductible, $1M landlord liability + $1M umbrella, loss of rents for 12 months, landlord contents $5k, water backup, and manager as additional insured.

  • Red flags (renegotiate or walk)

ACV-only roof on a relatively new roof, tiny water-backup limits ($1–2k), missing ordinance & law, big percentage wind/hail deductible in a hail zone, or exclusions for rental/short-term activity without a clear fix.

Bottom line: Decide up front whether you need a standard homeowners policy or homeowners insurance for rental property (landlord form), then lock your limits, deductibles, and endorsements. Request 3–5 homeowners insurance quotes with identical specs, compare the fine print (loss of rents, water backup, roof settlement), and bundle strategically. That’s how you get solid protection at a fair price—without surprises at claim time.